deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

November 21, 2007
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 113
Favourites: 0
Views: 190 (0 today)
[x]
Dear Seagate,

Please stop making hard drives that fuck up and die and lose my pretty pictures after 6 months of use.

And while I'm making a request you might want to make them NOT run so hot you could fry an egg on the top of the drive casing.

Thank you,
Philip

Foolhardy owner of three 300-400gb seagate drives that died within 6 months.  Fool me once, shame on you...

FOOL ME THRICE...  and I'm a cheap bastard who ought to stop buying drives on sale at Frys.
Add a Comment:
 
:icongrombolia:
~grombolia Apr 15, 2008   Digital Artist
Ive got a seagate, only about 4 months old, but i have to disconnect it every time i start up my computer other wise it freezes, and once it is connected, it slows down my computer to an almost snail pace, and yeah, mine gets really hot too... ive only got a 250G.
Reply
:iconroveberg:
I work in a large computer retail chain in Australia in the tech bay and I've had heaps of WD MyBook (external) drives come in for warranty replacement, but no such problems with Seagate FreeAgent (so far) so I recently reduced the amount of WD's we ordered and got more Seagates.

The WD problem doesn't seem to apply to their portable range though.
Reply
:icondragonfli:
China virus found in Seagate drives in Taiwan:

report
Mon Nov 12, 2007 4:52am EST

TAIPEI (Reuters) - U.S. computer hardware maker Seagate Technology (STX.N: Quote, Profile, Research) said some external disc drives sold in Taiwan had been infected with a virus which reportedly sent users' information to China, but it had since fixed the problem.
Reply
:iconstuckpixelphoto:
~StuckpixelPhoto Nov 26, 2007  Professional Photographer
Maxtor's are the worst drives available right now. At my day job this year alone I've had to have HP replace around 50 of the suckers (hp used to use them in their EVO line of PC's).

Seagates aren't as terrible as Maxtor drives really. As long as you either have adequate airflow or are using a hard drive cooling device they should last you. External Seagates though aren't fairing too well from what I've seen. The cases don't promote good airflow to cool the drive. Case in point: part of the reason I've been seeing a high failure rate with Maxtor drives in HP's Evo line is that the cooling is abysmal in their small form factor PC's (Evo D510 to present day Evo DC7700).

It also doesn't help too that I have a bunch of really stupid users who have a habit of blocking the sole ventilation fan that's blowing on the hard drive...

External drives are more prone to damage too (they're convenient, but moving them from place to place can take it's toll on them if you're not careful).

I know some people will probably disagree with this, but so far Western Digital has been the most reliable drive maker I have seen. I have them in my own PC's here at home, retrofitted my Series2 TiVo with two (older) 120GB WD HD's, and have built PC's for people using them. So far I've never had a catastrophic failure.

The drives that HP has been sending me for their Evo PC's have been either WD or Samsung. The latter has died on me though...
Reply
:icondragonfli:
Note to self: don't buy from Seagate

p.s. Fry's is awesome
Reply
:iconjeannieblue:
~Jeannieblue Nov 25, 2007  Hobbyist Photographer
That happens to me all the fucking time too! Thankfully, I have been through multiple drives/computers, but only ever lost perhaps 50 photos. But Santa, sign me up for that, as well! :nod:
Reply
:iconfron7runner:
~fron7runner Nov 24, 2007   Photographer
Fry's uses factory seconds, meaning they get crappy stuff. Not that I'm saying seagate is great hardware either.. I've heard Lacie is fairly reliable. As I look at the brand on my external: Seagate, I wonder about backing stuff up :(
Reply
:iconmasselements:
western digital. trust me. i build and sell badass computers.

they don't mess around.
Reply
:iconmikki-g:
I'll put in a vote for Samsung (SpingPoint) drvies. Fast, quiet and reliable. :)
Reply
:icondavid-woody:
*David-Woody Nov 24, 2007  Professional Photographer
A couple things I have to say about hard drives in general is you are taking a higher risk of losing data when you go over 250GB. I've been a technician for years and have seen many many 300+gig drives go down the shitter (of all brands). I'd stick with 250 gig drives in external enclosures. Maybe also back your shit up every once in a while to something more archivable like DVDs. The reason for this is that if you back up to a hard drive that won't be used often and want to archive that, the data can become corrupt over time and you'll get garbled images.

Ok and finally before I'm off...If you do want to go with larger drives than 250Gig you may think about a SCSI setup. Most SCSI drives are server quality and built to last. Expensive but better than losing work you may be getting paid for.

Peace I'm out!

~Dave
Reply
Add a Comment: